Reading
Group Questions
1. "When do I get a day?" Troy
asked Pam. Was his complaint legitimate? Is it possible to overdue church activities
and doing for God, to the neglect of family? Why or why not?
2. Why did Taylor agree to keep Luke's identity as father a secret? Do
you think she made the right decision? Why or why not? (See John 8:32; James
5:16.)3. Where do you draw the line between "sharing concerns" and "gossiping"?
(See Proverbs 11:13; 16:28; 18:8; 26:20. Contrast Ephesians 5:11-14.)
4. Now that you have "met" Pam, Taylor, and Yvonne, what impressions
have you formed about each woman?
5. Taylor reflects on how the church has responded to her as an unmarried mother—with
suspicion, contempt, judgment, assumptions about her character and availability.
How should the Christian church respond? (See Ephesians 4:29-32; Colossians 3:12-14.)
6. "I still supported Troy," Pam said, "…I didn't
back him 100 percent, but I was still in his corner." What does it mean
to you for a woman to support her husband (or for a husband to support his wife)?
What does such support look like?
7. Yvonne reflects on the "old school" versus contemporary views on
divorce. What do you think about it? Are today's women right or wrong to "take
no stuff" from a brother? Why?
8. Compare the plights of Taylor and Pam in chapters 7 and 8. With whom do you
most identify? How much sympathy do you have for the other? Whose situation is
worse? What does Jesus say about each challenge? (See Matthew 5:3-11.)
9. Contrast the attitude of Yvonne (chapter 6) and Taylor (chapter 9) concerning
the same charitable act (e.g., boys' clothes). How does Scripture deal
with giving and receiving "charity"? (See Matthew 6:1-4.)
10. Pam is shocked by Taylor's confession and doesn't know what to
say. How do we minister to those with whom we can't sympathize? (See James
2:12-13; 1 Peter 3:8-9.)11. Of the three people involved (Luke, Yvonne, Taylor),
whom do you find yourself holding most responsible for this "love triangle"?
Whom do you find most sympathetic? Why?
12. Pam said, "I'd trade this check to have Troy sitting next to me
on Sunday morning." What answer to prayer would you trade for $3.5 million?
(See Luke 16:19-31; James 5:5.)
13. Read the story of Hagar and Abram in Genesis 16. What it an apt Scripture
for Pam to cite to Taylor? Why or why not?
14. Compare Yvonne and Taylor's uncertain and ambivalent desire to talk
to each other about the affair (chapters 16,17,18). Where would you start if
you were in their shoes? What Scriptures might offer wisdom for the task?
15. Why did Pam's prayer feel like a betrayal to Yvonne? Have you ever
felt a desire to keep God on your side, not your "enemy's"? How
does Christ's exhortation in Matthew 5:44 address that dynamic?
16. Pam is aware that Troy is trying to reach out—but she isn't sure
how to reciprocate. How has anger kept you from building bridges across relational
chasms? (See Psalm 95:8; Matthew 6:14; Ephesians 4:32.)
17. Why is Taylor so suspicious of Spencer? Does she have grounds for it? Why
or why not?
18. Yvonne describes marriage as an electric fence—once her protection
and now a prison. How can the same relationship be both things? Can you empathize
with Yvonne's perspective? Why or why not?
19. What do you think about Pam's idea to invite both Yvonne and Taylor
to Jamaica? Was she crazy or courageous? A mediator or meddler? When have you
been stuck between two friends? How did you handle it?
20. Why can't Taylor just sit back and enjoy her date with Spencer? What
do you think Spencer might do to make her more comfortable (if anything)?
21. Is it true that "you can't hate someone that you're praying
for"? Why or why not? How does Taylor's prayer seem to break down
some of Yvonne's hostility?
22. What does it mean for Yvonne and Taylor that Yvonne voices her forgiveness?
Do you believe God really can open up such a relationship between two women with
that kind of history? Why or why not? (See Colossians 3:13; 1 John 1:9.)
23. The women (especially Pam) discover relief and joy in sharing their burdens
instead of hiding their cares. (See Galatians 6:2.) Why do we try to do it alone?
24. "I no longer respect this man as my husband. I don't acknowledge
his headship." Was Yvonne right or wrong to feel so? What does it mean for
her to recognize this shift in her feelings?
25. Taylor admitted that staying at New Faith became a form of penance; now she
realizes maybe she does want Spencer to judge her. Why? Why can't she (or
we) accept the grace of forgiveness?
26. "Everybody needs a tantrum now and then." Do you agree or disagree?
How can we express the violence of our emotions in healthy and appropriate ways?
27. Yvonne has already admitted she didn't know what forgiving Taylor would
mean. Now she is trying to sort out what it would mean to forgive a philandering
spouse. What does it mean?
28. Is Taylor right—should Pam go to Troy's shows? Why or why not?
How does 1 Peter 3:1 apply to such a decision?
29. Why did (or do) you want to get married? What changes might be necessary
for you to become a more effective spouse?
30. Have you ever felt like Pam—that life is speeding past and you want
to get it back? How can a Christian handle that feeling? (See Ecclesiastes 3:1-15;
12:1,13.)
31. What Scriptures fill your arsenal when you (like Taylor) are swamped by negative
accusations from the past or present?
32. While Yvonne just feels worn out and broken down, Pam views her transformation
into a strong and confident woman. How do such apparently negative emotions produce
strength of character? (See Romans 5:1-5.)
33. How do Taylor's responses to both Glenda and Spencer evidence real
growth in her character?
34. Have you ever had the feeling that you were "writing the wrong story" in
life? When? How did you respond?
35. How do Yvonne's reflections concerning the need to find herself, not
another man, relate to Paul's exhortation in 1 Corinthians 7:32-34?
36. How do you discern between passion and obsession? What does Scripture suggest
(see Proverbs 29:18; Joel 2:28; Titus 2:11-14)?
37. Yvonne agrees to attend Luke's hearing but doesn't know what
to say. What do you think she should do? What would you do? What insights might
Scripture offer? (See Romans 8:26-27.)
38. How do you answer tough questions (like Joshua's) from a child—your
own or someone else's? How can you help a child come to grasp with tough
realities in life?
39. "It's easy to be the victim," Yvonne told Taylor, "…but
you endured everyone's scorn." Do you agree: Is it easier to be the
victim? How does the church minister to the guilty and the innocent in such circumstances?
40. Troy wonders how to approach God in prayer. How do you talk to God—like
a friend, a parent, a king? How did Jesus talk to God? (See Matt. 6:9.)
41. A recurring theme in this book seems to be that appearances can be deceiving.
How does that theme relate to our ministry to others—and our ability to
allow others to minister to us?
42. What went wrong with Pam's visit to Troy's show? How would you
expect your spouse to handle the conflict between a professional commitment (like
Troy's tour) and your own due date?
43. Was Luke ever a "good husband" to Yvonne? Why or why not? How do
you (and Scripture) define a good husband? Is being a provider sufficient?
44. Pam seems to have it all—marriage, children, wealth, and now a fulfilled
dream—but she still feels hollow…sick and tired of being sick and
tired. How do you encourage yourself (or someone else) in that situation?
45. What does freedom or independence look and feel like to you? (See 2 Corinthians
3:17; Romans 6:18; Galatians 5:13; 1 Peter 2:16.)
46. More than once, Pam has envied her daughters' lack of inhibitions in
expressing their emotions, positive and negative. How do our adult masks obstruct
our relationships—with family, friends, and God? (No wonder Jesus said, "Unless
you come as little children…")
47. How does your own group of sisters (reading groups) compare to the Sister
to Sister group in this novel—for better and worse?
|